top of page

Internal Audit Reviews in Mortgage Servicing: Safeguarding Efficiency and Compliance


The mortgage servicing industry operates within a complex and heavily regulated landscape. Mortgage servicers are entrusted with managing a significant volume of loans, ensuring compliance with numerous laws, regulations, and investor guidelines. In such a dynamic environment, the importance of conducting regular internal audit reviews cannot be overstated. These reviews serve as a crucial mechanism to evaluate processes, identify weaknesses, and implement corrective measures. By doing so, internal audits contribute to maintaining operational efficiency, regulatory compliance, and risk mitigation within mortgage servicing portfolios.

Audit Plan: Setting the Foundation

To ensure the effectiveness of an internal audit review, it is vital to develop a comprehensive audit plan. The audit plan serves as a blueprint, outlining the scope, objectives, and methodology of the audit. It should consider relevant regulatory requirements, industry standards, and organizational goals. By defining the scope of the audit, identifying key risk areas, and allocating resources appropriately, the audit plan ensures a systematic and focused approach. Additionally, it assists in setting realistic timelines, facilitating effective communication, and ensuring that all necessary areas are covered during the review process.

Loan Level Testing: Assessing Compliance and Accuracy

Loan level testing is a critical component of internal audit reviews in mortgage servicing. It involves a meticulous examination of individual loans within the servicing portfolio to assess compliance with laws, regulations, investor guidelines, and internal policies. Loan level testing helps verify the accuracy of loan documentation, ensuring that all necessary information is present, accurate, and properly executed. It also involves assessing compliance with underwriting guidelines to confirm that loans were originated within the established parameters. Additionally, loan level testing ensures the proper calculation of interest rates, validates the disbursement of escrow funds, and evaluates the adherence to loan modification guidelines, if applicable. By conducting comprehensive loan level testing, internal audits can identify any gaps or discrepancies, allowing for timely remediation and proactive risk mitigation.

Writing of a Narrative: Documenting Findings and Recommendations

One of the key deliverables of an internal audit review is the writing of a narrative, which encompasses the findings and recommendations. The narrative serves as a detailed report that captures the essence of the audit, highlighting key observations, areas of concern, and potential improvements. It should provide a clear description of the audit methodology employed, the scope of the audit, and any limitations encountered during the review. Furthermore, the narrative should include a well-structured analysis of the identified issues, outlining their potential impact on the organization. To ensure effectiveness, the narrative should also offer practical recommendations for remediation, enabling management to take proactive steps to address the identified deficiencies. By documenting findings and recommendations in a concise and organized manner, the narrative facilitates transparency, aids in decision-making, and guides the implementation of effective corrective actions.

RACM (Risk Assessment and Control Matrix): Strengthening Internal Controls

An integral part of an effective internal audit process in mortgage servicing is the implementation of a Risk Assessment and Control Matrix (RACM). The RACM provides a systematic framework for identifying and assessing risks inherent in mortgage servicing operations, and establishing corresponding controls to mitigate those risks. By mapping risks to specific controls, the RACM enables auditors to evaluate the effectiveness of existing controls, identify control gaps, and recommend enhancements to strengthen internal controls. This iterative process ensures that controls evolve in response to changing regulatory requirements and emerging industry trends. The RACM serves as a dynamic tool for ongoing risk management, aiding in the identification and mitigation of potential vulnerabilities and ensuring regulatory compliance.

Final Audit Report: A Roadmap for Improvement

The final audit report is the culmination of the internal audit review process. It consolidates all the findings, observations, and recommendations, presenting a comprehensive overview of the audit's outcomes. The final audit report serves as a roadmap for improvement within the mortgage servicing organization.

A well-prepared final audit report provides stakeholders with a clear understanding of the audit's impact on the organization. It outlines areas of non-compliance, inefficiencies, and vulnerabilities that were identified during the review. By presenting these findings in a concise and easily comprehensible manner, the report enables management to prioritize and implement corrective measures effectively.

The final audit report should not only identify issues but also offer actionable recommendations for improvement. These recommendations should be practical, feasible, and tailored to the specific challenges identified during the audit. By providing clear guidance on how to address the issues, the report empowers management to take appropriate steps to enhance operational efficiency, regulatory compliance, and risk mitigation.

Moreover, the final audit report serves as a communication tool, facilitating dialogue between internal auditors and key stakeholders. It provides an opportunity for management to gain insights into potential weaknesses and operational gaps that may require attention. The report also helps foster a culture of accountability and continuous improvement within the organization.

In addition to addressing immediate concerns, the final audit report can be used as a reference for future audits and as a benchmark for measuring progress over time. By tracking the implementation of recommended improvements, organizations can demonstrate their commitment to addressing internal control deficiencies and enhancing their overall mortgage servicing operations.


Internal audit reviews play a crucial role in the mortgage servicing space, ensuring operational efficiency, regulatory compliance, and risk management. By developing a comprehensive audit plan, performing loan level testing, documenting findings in a narrative, utilizing the RACM framework, and preparing a comprehensive final audit report, organizations can proactively identify weaknesses, address compliance gaps, and enhance their overall performance.

The continuous evaluation of processes, systems, and controls through internal audit reviews helps mitigate potential risks, protect stakeholders' interests, and maintain the integrity of mortgage servicing operations. It is an essential practice for mortgage servicing organizations to foster transparency, accountability, and a culture of continuous improvement.

By investing in robust internal audit practices, mortgage servicing entities can navigate the evolving regulatory landscape with confidence, strengthen their operational frameworks, and ensure the highest standards of compliance and efficiency in their day-to-day operations.

The BlackWolf team has a deep understanding of the internal audit framework and has supported various mortgage servicers and banks by developing an internal audit schedule, managing and executing audits. Contact us today.


bottom of page